Overview

Tweet. Tweet.

    follow me on Twitter

    « Guerilla in the Board Room | Main | Designers Fight the Man »

    July 13, 2006

    Comments

    Eric Baker

    Serves you right for supporting *LAME,UNORIGINAL,POINTLESS,ANNOYING* TV shows about has been "rock" groups. You are the reason crappy show like this exist.

    alphamonkey

    Agreed. The Zen (which in my not very humble opinion is far superior to the iPod) can handle just about anything. If Creative Labs had an ounce of sense, they'd have marketed the Zen just as hard as the iPod and they'd probably dominate the market.

    spike

    Actually I'm pretty sure most MP3 players will play wma's. It's Apple that't the picky one... :-)

    Danopoly

    Satan C. Frogface! HA!

    Can I get that on a T-shirt?!

    Rob Mortimer

    Lets all relax and look forward to HDDVD vs BluRay. Hurrah for companies being SO stubbon that the consumer gets screwed over instead instead of them making a decision.

    Jen

    It's hilarious that I'm reading all of this now- just faced this very problem with iTunes vs. Microsoft, etc. It'd be nice if companies could come up with something other than proprietary file types and codecs to keep customers...

    Nathan

    Have got to love Microsoft.

    Who needs customer service or good ads when you have a big brand name? And as if improper advertising like this, along with not-so-great customer service could ever turn such a brand towards the direction of Mirco$oft, Microsuck, or Satan. Oops!

    Leigh

    You're all making me giggle. I appreciate all the technical info - but, it's an ad blog. I was just bitching about a crappy consumer experience. And, although I shall take this info and try other ways to play my songs on the player of my choice, I have to say, the response was quite unexpected!

    Q

    A Few Points of Information:

    1.) The iPod will play a variety of audio formats including: AIFF, WAV, Apple Lossless, MP3, AAC and AAC Protected.

    2.) The AAC format (Advanced Audio Coding) was not developed by Apple but is an open standard developed by the MPEG Standards Group. It is also known as MPEG-2 part 7 and MPEG-4 part 3.

    3.) Apple did develop "FairPlay" which is a Digital Rights Management system used by the iTunes Music Store.

    4.) Apple has, at this point, chosen not to license this technology to other companies. As a result, only iTunes, QuickTime (and QuickTime compatible applications), and the iPod can use files protected with "FairPlay".

    5.) iTunes and the iPod do not support other DRM schemes because: a.) Apple has chosen not to license these schemes from their owners and include them in the iPod, b.) the creators of these schemes have chosen not to license these schemes to Apple, c.) these schemes require Windows and/or Windows Media Player and would require either the creator or Apple to engineer the codec for QuickTime and Max OS.

    6.) FairPlay is as closed as PlaysForSure. PlaysForSure is as closed as FairPlay. If your digital audio player does not support PFS, it will not play those files. If you music was purchased using some other DMR scheme and your digial audio player only supports PFS, it probably won't play the file.

    Anyon

    Don't forget to pay pony up $10 to the author of the shareware!

    You already dumped $4 on Microsoft and some record labels. Might as well give $10 to the person/people who created a little program that allows you to enjoy that music.

    Leigh

    And the dream lives on! Thank you, Pope.

    POPE

    here, Advergirl, try this:

    https://macupdate.com/info.php/id/14645

    Rob Mortimer

    Isnt half of the issue with Apple being so restrictive on the format their players will accept..?

    E

    I thought iTunes converts WMA files when you import them - at least that's what mine did. However, it was probably protected WMA format which screws you over.

    Faris

    Saw an interesting article a while back on Apple's closed architecture and how it will spell doom

    Both do the same thing - try to tie you into to upgrading on to their next gen devices - if you change brand you can't use your music.

    Ultimately, as this guy below argues, this is pretty short sighted. The rise of the PC over the Mac was essentially because you could be IBM clones from anywhere.

    https://www.theage.com.au/articles/2006/04/01/1143441370852.html?from=top5

    Paul McEnany

    Really, I think you probably deserved it. That was just your punishment for watching that awful television show.

    Anyon

    To Apple's credit, converting an iTunes purchase over to an MPG requires burning a CD and then ripping the song from the CD. Then you can use it on ANY music player.

    Hardly the optimal solution, but that's what the record companies require.

    Annon

    Nice Blog. I hate to get picky but Apple does not use MPG either! They use AAC. iTunes is kind and clever enough to simply convert the format when it sends it out to your iPod. THAT is the difference between Microsoft and Apple.

    The comments to this entry are closed.

    Subscribe

    Your email address:


    Powered by FeedBlitz

    Look for me here, too

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button
    Blog powered by Typepad
    Member since 03/2004